Tag Archives: Pratchett

Review: A Hat Full of Sky by Terry Pratchett

This is Book Two in the Tiffany Aching series, a young adult series that’s part of the larger Discworld series.

In the series, the world is actually a disc that rides on the backs of four elephants standing on the back of a turtle.  The series currently has 39 books, but there are sub-series within the series and  they don’t need to be read chronologically.  Pratchett’s website describes the series a little like Star Trek – you can enjoy the episodes without starting from the first show, and if you’re not sure who the pointy eared guy is, you’ll figure it out as you go.

Pratchett was probably, until JK Rowling came along, the UK’s most successful fantasy writer.  He’s received four honorary degrees and was actually knighted in 1998.  He was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s Disease in 2007, and since then has raised money for Alzheimer’s research.  He’s been outspoken about his condition as well as his support for assisted suicide.

Discworld has spawned annual conventions in the UK as well as the United States.  In fact, when I was in Wisconsin a few weeks ago, the Discworld convention was happening in Madison at the same time, so Pratchett was profiled in Madison’s paper.  In the interview he says that one of his first American tour stops was in Madison, Wisconsin, to an audience of about 26 people.  He also reports that he bought a cheesehead.

Forgive the aside – I’m new to Terry Pratchett’s works, but I think he’s interesting and wanted to give you a little background.  I’m sure that with all the annual conventions, costumes, games, and movies, there ARE lots of Discworld experts out there, but I can’t claim to be one of them.

I read the first book in the series, The Wee Free Men, last year, and it’s high on my list of good fantasy YA fiction, up there with Garth Nix, Rowling, and a few others.  The difference is that Pratchett is FUNNY.  He writes a great fantasy story, but also manages to turn the fantasy genre on its head.  As a satirist, he honors the genre and makes fun of it at the same time.

But I really read Wee Free Men for its title characters, the Nac Mac Feegle: a gang of six-inch tall blue Scottish pictsies who wear kilts and love to fight, swear, throw things, and drink.  They also look after Tiffany Aching, an eleven year old witch-in-training. It helps if you enjoy Scottish dialect, so you can understand dialogue like:

“Oh, we saw some muckle eldritch places when we wuz raiding for the Quin,” said Rob Anybody.  “But we gave that up, for she wuz a schemin’, greedy, ill-fared carlin, that she was!” “Aye, and it wuz no’ because she threw us oout o’ Fairyland for being completely pished at two in the afternoon, whatever any scunner might mpf mpf…” said Daft Wullie.

“Pished?” said Miss Level.

“Aye… oh, aye, it means … tired. Aye. Tired.  That’s whut it means,” said Rob Anybody, holding his hands firmly over his brother’s mouth.  “An’ ye dinna ken how to talk in front o’ a lady, yah shammerin’ wee scunner!”

In Hat Full of Sky, Tiffany is sent as an apprentice to Miss Level, a witch in a nearby town.  Miss Level is a strange creature – she has two identical bodies but one mind, and can send one body out on errands while the other stays home.  She teaches Tiffany that witchcraft isn’t about spells and power but about caring for people. Most of the time that just means feeding them, cleaning up after them, and listening to them.  Tiffany doesn’t understand how that can be witchcraft.

Tiffany meets a group of other girls, all apprenticed to other witches in the area, and has to deal with the rivalry and insecurity that is typical of most pre-teen girls (witches or not).

I said in my review of Wee Free Men that despite the humor, these are surprisingly scary books.  Wee Free dealt with dreams you could get trapped in and never come out.  In Hat Full of Sky, Tiffany is stalked by a hiver just as she’s struggling to learn witchcraft.  What’s a hiver?  Some sort of disembodied spirit who doesn’t think and can’t be killed, but seeks to inhabit people with strong magical powers, like a parasite.  Once inside your head, the hiver imprisons your thoughts, takes away your free will and turns you into a monster.

So it’s scary, but still funny.  And I mean laugh-out-loud-on-the-bus-so-people-stare-at-you funny.  My favorite parts are when the Nac Mac Feegle set out to rescue Tiffany.  They don’t want to be seen by humans, so they all stuff themselves into a human-sized outfit (like a scarecrow) and try to pass themselves off as a human.  They think they’re fooling everyone – and fortunately the gold coins they hand out go a long way towards “erasing” people’s memories of a strange, wobbly blue creature where the head argues with the knees and the hands manage to go walking around by themselves.

Pratchett’s writing isn’t just funny, it’s clever.  He makes the kinds of observations you’ve thought but never put into words, like this one.  Miss Level is telling Tiffany about her experience working in a circus (having two bodies makes her an excellent circus performer).

“Have you ever been to a circus?”

Once, Tiffany admitted.  It hadn’t been much fun.  Things that try too hard to be funny often aren’t.  There had been a moth-eaten lion with practically no teeth, a tightrope walker who was never more than a few feet off the ground, and a knife thrower who threw a lot of knives at an elderly woman in pink tights on a big spinning wooden disc and completely failed to hit her every time.  The only real amusement was afterward, when a cart ran over the clown.

Tiffany is much more developed as a character in this book.  She really struggles with her role as a witch, what it means to take care of people (and when should people take care of themselves), homesickness, and being accepted by other girls.  Her life in Wee Free Men was sheltered and solitary.  Here she deals with jealousy, ambition, and embarrassment, even while fighting to save her body and mind.

Pratchett gives readers some surprisingly serious moments:

Silence spread out around Tiffany, a living silence, while the sheep danced with their lambs and the world turned.

Why do you go away?  So that you can come back.  So that you can see the place you came from with new eyes and extra colors.  And the people there see you differently, too.  Coming back to where you started is not the same as never leaving.

An all-around great book and definitely not just for kids.

1 Comment

Filed under Children and YA, Fantasy, Highly Recommended, Part of a Series

Review: The Wee Free Men by Terry Pratchett

The Wee Free Men is a children’s book, but like all good children’s books is just as funny and entertaining for adults.  Think Roald Dahl meets Harry Potter.

Wee Free Men is the first of four books about Tiffany Aching.  In Book 1, Tiffany is nine years old and thinking about becoming a witch.  She discovers that she has unusual powers when she is able to bash a sea monster over the head (using her sticky baby brother as bait).  She is visited by the Nac Mac Feegles, or the Wee Free Men, or the Pictsies – you choose your term.  The Feegles are six-inch tall kilt-wearing Scotsmen with blue skin and read hair who love drinking, fighting, and other rough activities.

The Wee Free Men are hilarious, and if you love all things Scottish half as much as I do, you’ll enjoy this book.  Also if you love the kind of tongue in cheek brand of fantasy you find in A. Lee Martinez or Christopher Moore or Douglas Adams.  Pratchett is excellent at turning all the witch-and-wizardry clichés on their heads (for example, pointing out that Tiffany is a most inappropriate name for a witch, or poking fun at schools for teenage witches and wizards).

At the same time, as with any good children’s book, it’s not all humor.  Tiffany struggles with resentment towards her baby brother, mourning the loss of a beloved grandmother, and generally feeling out of place in the world.  She comes to find that her brains, quick-thinking and courage are characteristics she can feel good about.  Tiffany learns a lot about who she is in the course of this book.  Perfect for any child who feels like a misfit.

The story begins with 9-year-old Tiffany deciding that a witch is what she wants to be. She seeks out a witch who can tell her more about witchcraft, not realizing that the witch is in fact looking for her. It turns out Tiffany is pretty powerful, despite being raised on chalk (because, of course, the soil is too soft to breed good witches).  Just as Tiffany’s trying to learn more about her abilities, an evil fairy queen steals Tiffany’s baby brother and threatens to unleash nightmare monsters into the world.

While the book is very funny, the fantasy story itself is pretty dark, including things like nightmares that become real and a fairy world you can become trapped in and lose your mind.

But all of my favorite children’s books are dark.  If you don’t realize how dark Roald Dahl, Frank Baum, Lewis Carroll, etc. could be, go back and read them some time.  There’s something about fantastic horror that is meaningful to kids.  Peggy Orenstein in Cinderella Ate My Daughter talked to a psychologist about the impact of Grimm’s Fairy Tales on children (the really gruesome classic versions), and was told that the fairy tales are actually an important way for children to process their fears about the real world.

But that suggests The Wee Free Men has some kind of deep psychological purpose.  I’m not sure that’s true.  I mainly like the little blue men in kilts who drink, swear, fight, and have names like “Slightly Bigger Than Wee Jock But Not So Big as Middle-Sized Jock Jock”.

I’d buy this for my nieces, and probably will.  It’s completely enjoyable, perfect for any YA or adult who loves a good fantasy story.  It reminded me a lot of a Harry Dresden (by Jim Butcher) story, but written for a slightly younger audience.  Book Two is A Hat Full of Sky — now I have one more book to add to my TBR list.

3 Comments

Filed under Children and YA, Fantasy, Highly Recommended, Part of a Series

Should I pick my next books based on Goodreads ratings?

Today I’m trying an experiment.  I looked at my Kindle and I have about 50 sample books stored up.  I can’t read all these samples, and even if I did, samples don’t always give you a good idea of whether you’ll like the book.

How do you choose your next book?  I like to switch around by category for one thing.  Then I’ll read the new stuff I’ve been waiting for.  I usually don’t read all the books in a series consecutively.  But after that it’s kind of a close your eyes and stick out your finger kind of process for me.

On Goodreads I can catalogue all the books I might want to read, and sort them by rating.  Goodreads typically has thousands of people rating books, which makes them a better gauge (I think?) than Amazon.  I don’t know if Library Thing or Shelfari are better or worse, but I know I don’t have time to explore all three.

So I entered in all the book samples and books I’m thinking of reading, so I could see which books get the highest reader ratings.  The result?  I have 57 books in the TBR list, and here’s GR’s top 20, in order by rating:

  1. The Wise Man’s Fear by Patrick Rothfuss (fantasy)
  2. Clockwork Angel by Cassandra Clare (fantasy)
  3. Good Omens by Terry Pratchett and Neil Gaiman (fantasy/humor)
  4. Poison Study by Maria Snyder (fantasy/YA?)
  5. The Iron Duke by Meljean Brook (fantasy)
  6. Trickster’s Choice by Tamora Pierce (fantasy/YA)
  7. The Kitchen House by Kathleen Grissom (lit. fiction)
  8. Crossing to Safety by Wallace Stegner (lit. fiction)
  9. Graceling by Kristen Cashore  (fantasy/YA)
  10. Assassin’s Apprentice by Robin Hobb (fantasy)
  11. The Tea Rose by Jennifer Donnelly (historical fiction)
  12. The Graveyard Book  by Neil Gaiman(fantasy/YA)
  13. Those Who Save Us by Jenna Blum (lit. fiction)
  14. The Thousand Autumns of Jacob de Zoet by David Mitchell (lit. fiction)
  15. A Dirty Job by Christopher Moore (fantasy/humor)
  16. Pump Six by Paulo Bacigalupi (fantasy/short stories)
  17. Room by Emma Donoghue (lit. fiction)
  18. War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy (classic)
  19. The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas (classic)
  20. To the End of the Land by David Grossman (lit. fiction)

This isn’t the order I would have expected but here it is.  Came up a little heavy on the fantasy/YA.  Interestingly, the lowest-rated on my list was a book called Something Red by Jennifer Gilmore which I started and didn’t like.  So that’s a good sign, right?

I added categories to these (guessing in some places) so I can pick one from each category to read next.  I guess this means my Kate Atkinson and TC Boyle, which ranked a little lower, will have to wait a bit. Help me out here — which ones would you recommend?

7 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized