Hag-Seed by Margaret Atwood

hagseedFor some reason I started this book several times; it didn’t quite grab me at first.  I suppose a story about a theater director seemed like it might be pretentious.  I should have realized that Margaret Atwood wouldn’t write a pretentious book.  Once I gave this book a couple of chapters, I was hooked.  And by the end of it, I was in awe of the great Margaret Atwood’s skill and talent.  She’s combined two things I love (Shakespeare and the power of education) into an entertaining and thoughtful story.

Hag-Seed is a re-telling of Shakespeare’s The Tempest.  It’s part of the Hogarth Shakespeare project, a collection of modern-day books that re-imagine works of Shakespeare (others include Vinegar Girl by Anne Tyler and New Boy by Tracy Chevalier).  Hag-Seed was nominated for the Bailey’s Women’s Prize for Fiction, but sadly it was not included in the shortlist (I haven’t yet read any of the shortlisted books, so can’t compare).

I was skeptical about this book because I’m not a huge fan of retellings of classics, because they tend to feel forced.  An author retelling a classic has a set of plots and characters they have to include, which often don’t make much sense in a modern context.  Certainly, there are some good ones: A Thousand Acres by Jane Smiley, The Story of Edgar Sawtelle by David Wroblewski, Bridget Jones Diary by Helen Fielding.  But a retelling of The Tempest seemed a much more challenging task, with magic and fairies, enslavement, goddesses and goblins. Although it’s been done before, in the 1956 movie Forbidden Planet.

I’ve read and seen The Tempest a few times.  Its themes of enslavement and exile make it one of Shakespeare’s more disturbing plays.  But this book gave me a much greater appreciation for the complexity (and at times absurdity) of the story.

Felix Phillips is a theater director who is about to stage The Tempest when he is betrayed by his assistant and fired from his job.  He recently lost his young daughter Miranda and he hasn’t recovered; understandably, it has affected his work.  But without his work, he’s lost.

Atwood tells the story of The Tempest in a brilliant way: through the eyes of a group of low-security prison inmates who’ve signed up for a literature class taught by Felix.  His class requires the students to stage a Shakespeare play from start to finish, and then he adds some writing assignments where students must reflect on 1) how the play can be adapted for its modern-day audience of inmates; and 2) what they think might happen to the characters after the play.

This set-up allows Atwood to explore complicated themes in The Tempest without it feeling forced.  At the same time, there are clear parallels between the characters in the novel (Felix as Prospero, for example) and the characters in the play.  In a way, she tells The Tempest’s story not just once, but twice.  There are layers upon layers in this book.

When I started the novel, I thought it was going to be a “should read” but maybe not one I’d enjoy.  I was surprised to find I raced through this novel in a couple of days, and enjoyed every minute.

Atwood’s book embraces an idea I feel strongly about: that all people, not just theater and literature snobs, can enjoy (and be shaped by) classic literature.  Shakespeare wrote for the masses, after all.  But it’s more than that.  It’s also the idea that all people can rise to our expectations given the right kind of teaching.  The correctional facility where Felix works didn’t believe the prisoners could understand Shakespeare.  And yet everyone – teacher, students, and audience – grows from the experience.

You might be saying at this point that it sounds awfully feel-good, and not terribly realistic.  It sounds like one of those hackneyed teacher-saves-downtrodden-students movies.  I’ll admit, I’m a sucker for a good teaching story.  But Atwood’s use of dialogue and her clever layering of The Tempest‘s plot make the story feel realistic and new.  For example, Felix tells his students that swearing will be forbidden in his class – UNLESS they are swearing in Shakespeare’s terms.  The students are asked to go through the play and make a list of all Shakespeare’s insults.  Then they can use those insults on each other freely — and they do.  This is where the title “Hag-Seed” comes from.  It’s an insult aimed at Caliban, who is the ill-begotten son of a witch, Sycorax. It’s an odd, even off-putting title for a book, but it makes perfect sense once you’ve read it.

There’s a rather odd emphasis on rape in some parts, and if this was a male writer I’d be bothered by it.  I think it’s Atwood wrestling with that rather ugly part of the story, where Caliban’s revenge upon Prospero is the rape of his daughter.  Miranda is played as passive, a prize to be won or taken by force.

In fact, this one of many areas where Atwood wrestles with the complexities and tensions of The Tempest.  I absolutely loved the joy that Atwood brings to this telling of a dark and very strange story.

22 Responses to “Hag-Seed by Margaret Atwood”

  1. Elle

    I adored this, and you’re right – it’s the layers of story that make it so compelling, the way she creates parallels between her characters and the play’s and then has her characters create their own mental parallels. I loved the way the plot allowed her to openly discuss the story; it struck me as a much more productive technique than other retellings have used.

  2. Nish

    I don’t like retellings very much too, but this sounds pretty good. I should give it a try.

    • curlygeek04

      I’m glad I’m not the only one! They are so hard to do really well. If you like Shakespeare at all you should try this book.

  3. Katy Goodwin-Bates

    I really liked this too, although I am an Atwood superfan so this didn’t surprise me. I found Hagseed really funny in a lot of places, but, as you say, very dark in others. I saw Atwood talking about it at a bookish event before reading it which made Hagseed even better because I heard her voice as I read, and her voice is awesome. Excellent review!

    • curlygeek04

      What I love about Atwood is her range — this book didn’t seem anything like what she’s written recently. I thought it had a great sense of humor too. I worried it was going to be darker than it was.

  4. lucindablogs

    I’ve just read and reviewed this! I love Margaret Atwood so I did enjoy the book but I thought that I needed to be more familiar with the Tempest to get the most out of

  5. lucindablogs

    …Hag-Seed (sorry I’ve got a splinter in my finger and I can’t type properly!) I could see all of the layers in parts of the story but felt like I was missing some in other areas. I listened to the audiobook and the last chapter was a summary of the Tempest which I thought should have been at the beginning. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

    • curlygeek04

      There was a lot about the Tempest I didn’t remember until I read the summary, and I’ve seen it a few times. After I read the summary I was more impressed at how she pulled it all together. But that was definitely the English major in me!

  6. Gwen

    I avoided Vinegar Girl because I’m tired of retellings, but I don’t know, I might want to read this now! I do trust Margaret Atwood to do it better than most.

    • curlygeek04

      I haven’t heard great things about Vinegar Girl, and I really haven’t seen any reviews of the other ones. I found this very different from Atwood’s other books, but just as good.

  7. Marie

    Excellent review! I loved this book too! I even went back and read The Tempest afterwards, and even more so loved how Atwood handled this retelling.

    • curlygeek04

      I’m impressed that you re-read The Tempest afterward! That’s a great idea. I really appreciated that this book included a detailed summary of the plot, since there were plenty of details I wasn’t sure about.

      • Marie

        I was also trying to fulfill the Book Riot’s reading challenge and needed to read a play, so it seemed like a great choice.

  8. Col

    I’d been avoiding this as I’d been put off by Vinegar Girl!! I’m a fan of everything else Ann Tyler’s done whereas Margaret Atwood tends to be a bit hit and miss for me. So using that less than scientific formula I’d decided to give Hag-Seed a body swerve. Now I’ve changed my mind!

  9. BookerTalk

    Ive been avoiding these retellings out of a sense that they could be either superficial or contrived as he author tries to force fit their narrative to the original. But this sounds very clever so I shall give it a go – and hope it proves my prejudices lead me down the wrong path sometimes

  10. JaneGS

    I loved this book! I agree that the premise totally worked for Atwood to go off on her interpretation of The Tempest without the lit crit feeling forced. I totally loved how Ariel was handled, and Miranda and the blending of them. I’ve only ever read one other Atwood, which I didn’t like (Blind Assassin), but I’m a believer now!

  11. Lory @ Emerald City Book Review

    I find that Atwood can always be relied on to be an author of integrity, and that’s worth a lot in today’s world. I’m glad you enjoyed this so much — it’s definitely moving up on my to-read list.

  12. Favorite Books of 2017 | The Book Stop

    […] Hag-Seed by Margaret Atwood: One of my favorite Atwood books, I love how she intertwines The Tempest with a modern-day theater director and his work teaching inmates of a juvenile detention facility about Shakespeare and theater. There are so many layers in this book.  It not only gave me a better understanding of The Tempest, it was a pleasure to read. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Basic HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

%d bloggers like this: