Last month I read two fantastic books that were the authors’ debut novels (The Hate U Give and The Leavers). That got me thinking about other great first novels I’ve read, which got me to thinking: why are so many authors’ first novels their best ones?
I think it’s because there’s a raw, emotional quality to a first novel. The novels that follow may be more sophisticated, but they often lack the emotional punch. I’ve often read that many people become writers because they have a story in them that needs to be told — and this story becomes their first novel but it may be hard to replicate. A related reason is that first novels tend to be the most autobiographical (again, back to the emotional punch).
Having an amazing debut novel is both a positive and a negative. The upside is that many of these first works are among our greatest literary works. The down side is that for whatever reason, the books they published later didn’t resonate as much.
Of course many authors have great debut novels and go on to publish even better works. And identifying an author’s best novel is entirely subjective. Is Sense and Sensibility Jane Austen’s best work? Is The Edible Woman Margaret Atwood’s best work? How about The Bluest Eye for Toni Morrison? Impossible to say.
Maybe the magnum opus first novel is the exception, not the rule. But when I looked for good examples of powerful first books, I found many examples that resonated:
The following authors only published one novel but it was a great one. Plath, Wilde, and Salinger wrote plays, poetry, novellas and short stories but only one novel. Harper Lee and Ralph Ellison both had uncompleted fiction published posthumously. John Kennedy Toole died before even publishing his first work.
And then there are authors who haven’t come out with their second novel yet, but some of us are waiting anxiously. These authors experienced great success and critical acclaim with their first novels, which must create quite a lot of pressure.
I only included novels I’ve read on this list, with the exception of Catch-22, and that one because it’s a favorite of so many (and because I mean to finish it one day). For a list of great debut novels, see here and here.
Do you agree or disagree about the power of the first novel? Do you have other favorite first novels?
"She had read novels while other people perused the Sunday papers" - Mary Elizabeth Braddon
"The world was hers for the reading"
Thoughts on Literature, Expressing Creativity, Being Authentic
books, libraries, life
Reading, Writing, Cats - Life is pretty good.
Books and Beverages
Book Recommendations From One Book Lover to Another
We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars. Oscar Wilde
A book blog. Plus a little extra.
A Life Amidst Books
Reading for the critical eye
Reviewing books, society, adulthood, and more.