Review: In the Shadow of Statues by Mitch Landrieu

I saw Mitch Landrieu on the Daily Show a few months ago and immediately put this book on my TBR list.  It’s a fascinating look at race and the history of the American South, from slavery to Civil War to Civil Rights.  As the title indicates, the book is about how three confederate monuments were taken down in New Orleans.  But as it turns out, much of the book is not about that particular action, but all the events and ideas that led up to it.

Landrieu starts this book with his childhood, and recounts his steps towards racial awareness.  I was struck by this paragraph, which describes his visit to Auschwitz.

I had not yet thought about why there were no markers of the atrocities committed on our land, in our city. Why no slave ship markers? Why no plantation histories told through the eyes of the enslaved Africans who worked them? That would come to me later. Auschwitz laid a foundation, a building block, in my mind, not only for how evil humans can be to one another, but also for how we can reckon with and learn from our past so as to not repeat the same mistakes in the future.

Landrieu goes from his own upbringing and career choices to his work with New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina.  He finally gets to his decision, based on the request of a friend, to research the history of Confederate monuments in his beloved city and whether it’s legally possible to take them down.  It’s this part of the book that’s most interesting.  Landrieu seems genuinely shocked by the vitriol that accompanied his decision, and I was shocked by it as well.

It’s not a perfect book, but it is an informative one. And while I recommend it to anyone interested in New Orleans, racial issues, and our country’s history, I have to qualify my recommendation for two reasons.

  • This is history wrapped up in Landrieu’s own personal reflections, and likely his political ambitions. There’s quite a bit of self-congratulation in here, from Landrieu’s handling of racial issues to his handling of Hurricane Katrina. And a lot of name-dropping as well. I could have done with less of that.  But it’s his story.
  • This is a book about race, told by a white man — and not just any white man, but one who’s grown up in a family that’s practically a Louisiana dynasty. But Landrieu acknowledges his privilege frequently, and he also acknowledges the many others who have influenced his views. Clearly there are writers of color you should read, but Landrieu does have a story to tell, and it’s important that he tell it.

I really appreciated this book for the way it lays out the history of the South, and the way African-Americans have been terrorized by white people over and over again.  It seems the more African-Americans gain basic legal rights, the more they are attacked and threatened by the people who fear those rights.  When you look at what happened after the Civil War, and then the Civil Rights era, you see that clearly.  This is not about the bigotry of 50 years ago or 150 years ago.  It’s about today.

What’s impactful about this book is how Landrieu clarifies the history of these monuments and the message they are sending.  I think many white people genuinely believe, as we’ve heard so often, that the monuments are memorializing our country’s history and honoring the people who died in the Civil War.

All of this happens in the shadows of statues whose message has always been, as Terence Blanchard said: African Americans are less than.

Lately I’ve been paying more attention to the historical sites of DC, and the way this region has been trying to better teach the history of slavery.  I’ve seen it in Colonial Williamsburg, in Jamestown, and in Mount Vernon.  In Monticello, there’s the first real exhibit about Sally Hemings.  In Alabama there’s the first memorial to the victims of lynching.  In some places, this new awareness is eye-opening.  And in others it’s sadly inadequate.  It’s like we’re just starting to take notice of what Landrieu realized in Auschwitz – that as a country we can’t move forward until we begin taking responsibility for the crimes we’ve committed.

This book, at least, is a place to start.

6 Responses to “Review: In the Shadow of Statues by Mitch Landrieu”

  1. Lory @ Emerald City Book Review

    “As a country we can’t move forward until we begin taking responsibility for the crimes we’ve committed.” This is so true, and it’s so overwhelming because the crimes are huge.

    I’ve been reading about the idea of the “shadow” in psychological transformation, and we can see in this country how we have a shadow literally projected onto the dark-skinned of our society. It’s like a mythological motif that has persisted into the modern age, and we have to overcome it by penetrating through the primal fears and superstitions that underlie it.

    Some people are courageously making steps out of the darkness, though, and this sounds like one example.

    Reply
    • curlygeek04

      Thanks Lory, I appreciate your thoughts on this! I’ve been reading about the new Sally Hemings exhibit at Monticello, where she’s portrayed as a shadow, and I really want to see it. I’d be interested in how this idea relates to what you’re reading about.

      There’s a sense that Landrieu wrote this book to gear up for a potential run for higher office. So there’s definitely some self-interest there, but it will be interesting to see where that goes.

      Reply
  2. Elle

    It seems to me that Landrieu’s whiteness and privileged-ness might actually make this a good gateway book for someone who doesn’t fully understand why these statues aren’t about memorialising the war dead, or who doesn’t have a strong sense of present-day American racism: he functions as a member of a social circle that such readers are almost certainly more willing to listen to than, e.g., Ta-Nehisi Coates. (By the way,, you’ll have read the news about the toppling of Silent Sam in Durham – have you read the transcript of the remarks made when the statue was officially unveiled in 1913? They make Terence Blanchard’s point brutally clear: these memorials are ALL about white supremacy.)

    Reply
    • curlygeek04

      That’s a really good point, I did think about that. He’s writing from a fairly unique vantage point. I heard about Silent Sam but definitely want to read more!

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Basic HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

%d bloggers like this: