Review: The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek by Kim Michele Richardson

I wasn’t sure what to expect from this book, but I ended up finding it both fascinating and moving. I knew it was about a true-life group of people in the Appalachians with blue skin, and it was also about the historic Packhorse Librarians, women who delivered library books on horseback to families in the mountains. I thought it was going to be nonfiction, but it’s a historical novel. I listened to the audiobook, read by Katie Schorr (who also narrated The Hating Game). This is a book with a lot of dialect, so listening to it was helpful.

The book takes place in 1936 in Troublesome Creek, Kentucky. A young woman, Cussy Mary Carter, is one of the Blue People – in fact she believes she’s the last of their kind. The Blue People are hated, feared, and scorned by nearly everyone living in the area. To some, she’s the devil, and to others, she’s “colored.” And yet she spends her days riding through dangerous mountains on the back of a mule, just to give families their only chance to borrow a magazine, novel, or a children’s book. She tries to instill in the families on her route a love of reading, even teaching some of them basic reading skills.

Her mother is dead, her father works a dangerous job in the mines – particularly dangerous because he’s a labor organizer as well. She has no other family and most of the time, not enough to eat. But she loves her job as a Packhorse librarian.

I loved the way Richardson shows in this story the power that a few books can have on a struggling family. For these very isolated people, reading is a window to the rest of the world. It’s a way for them to connect with each other. The people on Cussy Mary’s route all have different dreams, whether it’s fighting fires, getting married, baking a pie, or educating their child. And for each of these families she picks out a magazine or book that may help them get there. In her free time she creates scrapbooks that help the neighbors share medical lore, recipes, and household tips. By creating and sharing these scrapbooks, she helps to build a community across neighbors. When a father becomes angry that his kids are too distracted by books and don’t finish their chores, she convinces him to let the kids read Boy Scout guides about fishing and hunting and knot-tying.

I’ve always believed that books can change people’s lives, and that everyone should have access to reading materials. I worked for many years on a program that did just that. So this part of the story was really inspiring.

The other primary aspect of the story is racism and prejudice, and again, Richardson tells a powerful story. Particularly interesting is when Cussy Mary and her father have to grapple with whether the blue of their skin is a medical condition or just who they are. Can it be changed? And if it could, would it change who they are, or how people treat them? Unfortunately, there are some truly horrible scenes in this book about people’s hatred of those who are different. The Blue People may be unusual, but sadly, the way they are treated is not unusual at all.

Richardson explains at the end of the book that she interviewed a number of families in Kentucky and also spoke to medical researchers, as well as doing extensive research on the Packhorse Librarian program. The author lives in Kentucky, and gives this book a very strong sense of place. She set the book in the 30’s because that program was part of the New Deal, a way to alleviate the extreme poverty of the area by helping people get jobs that would also address community needs. It clearly helped women who had no other family support and couldn’t apply for most jobs.

Richardson explains that she had to take some liberties with the timeline, because the medical research she discusses in the book didn’t actually occur until years later. I do appreciate when authors explain why they make changes in historical narratives.

The book does start off a bit slow; the first third almost felt like a string of anecdotes rather than a cohesive story. Readers who aren’t as obsessed with books and reading as I am may find the pace a bit frustrating. It does pick up though, and I’m glad I stayed with it. This was a moving story that felt sincere but never melodramatic or overstated. The poverty, hunger, and prejudice felt very real, as did the warmth and kindness that some of the characters showed each other during very hard times.

10 Comments on “Review: The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek by Kim Michele Richardson

  1. This sounds like my kind of book, and I’m sure I wouldn’t have come across it without this review! Thank you for sharing this! Lovely writing also

  2. What an interesting history-based story and I’m glad it was done so well! I don’t mind if authors change details like the one you mention in historical fiction, as long as they explain.

    • Yes, I love when authors provide clear explanations for what they changed. Often there are very good reasons. The Packhorse Librarians went away after World War II, so the story couldn’t have been told in another time, but the medical research was pretty interesting.

  3. I loved this book, but you know, Richardson didn’t write hardly any of the dialects into her prose, and yet I had a southern accent in my head the whole time reading it – so I don’t think that it would have been hard to read a print version, but I’m glad the audio version was good for you.

    • That’s an interesting observation. I thought it was a very good audiobook – I can’t say whether the dialects were authentic or not but I enjoyed listening to it.

  4. I’ve heard about the packhorse librarians but not the blue-skinned people of Kentucky! I have to read this book–so many incredible themes bundled together. Thanks for a wonderful review–I’m okay with slow beginnings, if I know the story is ultimately worth it.

  5. Pingback: 2020: My Year in Audiobooks – The Book Stop

  6. Fab review! I love this one too! I so agree with how sincere and real this felt. I read this a year ago and still remember it well. Cussy Mary was an incredibly strong character. The research that went into this one was amazing!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

She Reads Novels

"She had read novels while other people perused the Sunday papers" - Mary Elizabeth Braddon

Relevant Obscurity

"The world was hers for the reading"

Word by Word

Thoughts on Literature, Expressing Creativity, Being Authentic

Spines in a Line

books, libraries, life

Speedy Reader

Reading, Writing, Cats - Life is pretty good.

The Green Tea Librarian

Books and Beverages

Silver Button Books

Book Recommendations From One Book Lover to Another

For Book Lovers and Random People

We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars. Oscar Wilde

The Lowrey Library

A book blog. Plus a little extra.

Bookshelf Fantasies

A Life Amidst Books

The Perspicacious Bookworm

Reading for the critical eye

NerdyWordyBirdy

Reviewing books, society, adulthood, and more.

%d bloggers like this: